Junction Township dispute results
in second resignation


Wayne White |
Managing Editor

Ongoing disputes among Junction Township board members has led to the second and possibly a third board member’s resignation within a month. In May, then township clerk Virgil Scheid submitted his resignation to the Osage County Commission after township trustee Chuck Trautman accused him of not discharging his duties as clerk.

Monday, Trautman appeared before the commissioners, first discussing the reasons for which he said he had asked Scheid to resign. Before the discussion ended, Trautman indicated his wife, Janet Trautman, would be resigning her position as township treasurer and he would resign as trustee.

Chuck Trautman said when he first asked Scheid to resign, “He laughed at me and said that he would stay on for two years and make me suffer every minute of it. So I see what my suffering is.”

Trautman complained, “[Scheid] then goes behind our back and comes into this meeting here and resigns here.”

Osage County Commissioner Carl Meyer later explained to Trautman that Scheid followed proper procedure by submitting his resignation to the county commission.

“He can’t resign to the township board, he has to come here,” Meyer said.

Trautman then turned his complaints to a discussion he held with county counselor Delton Gilliland at a county commission meeting May 26, during which Gilliland questioned Trautman about payments made to the township treasurer for taking deposits to the bank.

“I was slammed down the throat by Mr. Gilliland here about $120,” Trautman said.

Trautman’s comments elicited Gilliland’s suggestion that the commission limit the discussion.

“Mr. Chairman,” Gilliland said to Meyer, “you could listen to five hours of complaints about something that’s occurring in another municipality. I would suggest the board ask for comment on something that is within the jurisdiction of county government.”

With discussion continuing, Trautman questioned the commissioners about how they would react “if you were chairman of this board and either one of those refused to sit at the table with you and refused to sign documents or checks, would you ask for his resignation?”

Osage County Commissioner Kenneth Kuykendall responded that elected officials could not demand each other’s resignations.

“He’s elected and you’re elected,” Kuykendall said. “This is a three-member board same as you have, you all vote two to one. I don’t see what your issue is. If one is not doing what you want, you still have a two to one majority. He is still an elected official … you’re both legally elected, whether it’s right, wrong or indifferent.”

Trautman also confronted Osage County Mike Pruitt about comments Pruitt made at a recent township meeting.

“Mr. Pruitt you were at one of our meetings and as you left you stopped by our table and said we were doing a great job,” Trautman said, “and now you turned the rattlesnake into the cage, what was the purpose of that?”

Trautman said he was referring to the county commissioners’ appointment of Don Croy to fill Scheid’s vacancy.

Croy, who was present at Monday’s commission meeting, objected to Trautman’s comments and said he had conducted himself in a professional manner at all meetings he had attended.

“[Croy] has not had one positive comment toward us in the last three meetings,” Trautman said.

Trautman said the disputes had led to his wife requesting to resign as township treasurer.

“I’m also letting you know that I too am offering my resignation,” Trautman said. “I do not have the support of the commissioners or the county counselor … what’s my point of being here?”

Gilliland questioned whether Janet Trautman had submitted a written resignation.

“The board can’t operate on a verbal resignation,” Gilliland said, noting Janet Trautman was not present to submit her resignation.

“Do you have a written resignation?” Gilliland asked Chuck Trautman, who began writing his resignation on a legal pad.

Meyer opened the meeting to public comment, hearing first from Chuck Sypher, a resident of Fairfax Township and subdivision on Pomona Lake’s south shore.

“I really hate to see him resign because everyone in our area is commenting on the improvement in our roads,” Sypher said. “It’s the first time we’ve really had what I consider responsive maintenance. We have fought this issue for years.”

Sypher also said he wished to clarify a letter he sent to the county commission in May, which he said had been misrepresented by unnamed persons.

“I did send a letter to the commissioners in support of Mr. Trautman,” he said. “We were very appreciative of the county and the townships – the two townships worked together to knock down that hill going into South Shore. The issue was however they were about 90 percent done and they pulled all their equipment out of there. My support for Mr. Trautman was that his men were coming down that hill and were continuing to improve that access road and it’s the best it’s ever been right now.”

Sypher also noted that for the first time in eight years he had seen a grader maintaining roads in the housing development where he lives.

“I don’t want to go back to that old style of government,” he said.

Commissioners also heard from Gary Summers who lives in Junction Township and in a housing development near Vassar. He said the township had been maintaining his road for the 34 years he had lived there. But since new board members were elected, “the water runs down the middle of the road, we haven’t had any gravel put on the roads to speak of,” Summers said. He offered to fill the position left vacant by Trautman’s resignation.

Two other Fairfax Township residents spoke in favor of Trautman, citing improved road conditions.

Trautman said the only reason he ran for township trustee was to improve the roads. He also said he had persuaded his wife to run as treasurer.

“She didn’t want to and I didn’t blame her,” Trautman said. “And anyone who would stand in line for this position has got brain damage.”

With the commission unanimously accepting Trautman’s resignation, Meyer asked if anybody was interested in being appointed to township board.

Summers was the only person to respond, bringing an outburst from Trautman.

“Are you going to ramrod him in there too, like you did the last one or you going to follow proper procedure?” he asked, saying he believed the commission should advertise the vacancy before making an appointment.

“It’s never been done that way,” Kuykendall said. “Traditionally it’s almost impossible to get people to volunteer to be on a township board.”

On Pruitt’s motion, the commission unanimously appointed Summers as Junction Township trustee.

Sypher also objected, “I don’t believe best practices have been followed here, either with Mr. Croy’s nomination or with Mr. Summers. I don’t think the procedure is really correct.”

“It is standard practice for us to appoint people to townships,” Kuykendall said. People retire and resign from townships constantly. If you can in general find someone willing to be on townships, you better grab a hold of them, because we’ve got empty holes now that we can’t find people to fill on townships.”

Kuykendall also expressed his opinion that township form of government “is ancient and antiquated, but it’s what we have.”