Carbondale City Council
Officer cleared of wrongdoing

From staff reports


CARBONDALE—Carbondale Police Officer Greg Wallace has been cleared of wrongdoing after a Missouri police department’s investigation of a disturbance at Carbondale’s Sept. 13 street dance.

The Carbondale City Council requested the investigation of Wallace after a parent alleged improper treatment of her minor child following an incident at the dance. Carbondale City Attorney Sue DeVoe confirmed Wallace was the subject of more than one written complaint received by the city regarding the incident.

At the Sept. 15 meeting of the city council, a mother claimed that her daughter was forced to the ground by Wallace and handcuffed because of pushing and shoving going on within a group of people. Another mother said her daughter was assaulted by someone in the group and had to flee from the disturbance. During that meeting, the council approved requesting an outside law enforcement agency to conduct an independent investigation. After the Kansas Bureau of Investigation declined to investigate the incident, the Holt, Mo., police department was requested to investigate.

At the Oct. 20 council meeting, council president Mike Fulton announced the investigation was incomplete and further investigation would be needed.

Oct. 29, the council held a special meeting to consider an investigation report submitted by Holt Police Chief Michael Noland. Following a 17-minute executive session, Fulton read from Noland’s investigation report, “It is my findings through this supplemental investigation as it was in the preliminary investigation that Officer Wallace conducted himself in a safe and professional manner given the situation which was at hand the night of the incident.”

Fulton said the report was “basically clearing [Wallace] of any wrongful actions.”

“We’re very sorry this had to happen,” Carbondale Mayor Ruth Towne said. “It’s been hard on Officer Wallace, his family and the town.”

Fulton had previously said the council wished to “get this thing over with as soon as possible,” and at last week’s special meeting declared the issue resolved, but at least one citizen questioned the validity of the investigation. Monday, at the regular council meeting, Scott Hite expressed concern about why he was not interviewed about the incident. He said there were many witnesses who had not been interviewed.

Hite said he believed the investigation was handled improperly and also questioned why the council held a special meeting to review the findings instead of waiting until the regular council meeting.

Councilman Daryl Makowski echoed Fulton’s earlier comment and said that a special meeting was called to resolve the incident as soon as possible.

Another citizen, Marvin Stevens, said, “It looked deceiving to hold a special meeting on a Wednesday night when it could have been done at the regular council meeting.”

Answering Hite’s complaint about the investigation, Carbondale Police Chief Adam Marion said he had secured statements from Debbie Traphagen and her daughter, who was involved in the incident, and Wallace. That information was faxed to the investigator in Holt, Mo, he said.

Traphagen questioned several times during Monday’s meeting, “Who are you going to believe, a 12-year-old girl or a police officer?”

Marion said Wallace had acted properly when he saw the fight going on between three girls. Wallace was trying to prevent someone from getting hurt, Marion said, and he had to get the incident under control quickly.

Someone asked why the other two girls were not handcuffed. The reason given was that Wallace was the only officer at the scene at that time.

Following the discussion Monday, the council agreed the issue had been resolved.

Marion said Tuesday he was relieved that allegations against Wallace had been settled, but said the issue had been overblown by townspeople.

“It was handled just the way it should have been,” Marion said of the incident and Wallace’s actions.

Regarding the resulting reaction to the incident, Marion said, “It was a silly situation that should have never turned into what it did.”

Marion said charges are pending against three juveniles involved in the incident.

DeVoe announced at last week’s special meeting no disciplinary action had been taken against Wallace. She declined this week to release any of the investigation report, citing it as a personnel matter.

In other Monday business, the council:

considered changes to the Hinck commercial site sewer project to accommodate the State Bank of Carbondale’s request to be connected to the sewer line. Ben Kramer of Kramer Engineering explained two plans that could serve the bank, one which would have included service to a vacant block for future development. Another option was to set the main sewer line deeper to serve the vacant lot if needed in the future at an additional cost of $3,000. The council approved councilman Clint Vawter’s motion for the second option. Cost of the sewer project is estimated at $64,735.

approved a motion by Fulton to request approval to increase the loan for the water project. Carbondale City Clerk Sandy Schiffelbein was instructed to send a letter to contractors for the project, informing them bills will be paid when the city receives additional funds from the Kansas Department of Health and Environment loan.

approved a request from maintenance supervisor Kevin Richardson to send newly hired maintenance employee Jared Kleier to a one-day training in Ottawa at no cost to the city except for wages.

• approved a request from Richardson to rent a two-man lift basket from Sunflower Rentals for one day to install Christmas lights on Dec. 1, at a cost of $370.